Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
9006 Update and REEE Opportunities in CO
  • John Brown
  • State and Local Initiatives
  • 303.275.3615
  • john_brown@nrel.gov
2
 
3
Major Research Programs
4
Renewable Technologies
  • Wind
  • Solar
  • Biomass
  • Anaerobic Digestion
  • Geothermal
  • Hydrogen
5
Market Drivers for Renewables
  • Declining Costs
  • Fuel Price Uncertainty/Risk Mitigation
  • Energy Security
  • Rural Economic Development
    • New jobs & economic development
    • Increased economic diversity
  • Zero or reduced air emissions
  • Reduced public health costs related to pollution
  • Emerging Markets for Green Power and Emissions
  • Federal and State Policies
    • RPS, 9006
6
 
7
Environmental Drivers
  • Compliance with state and federal statutes
  • Health impacts
  • Land, air, water impacts
  • Climate change


8
 
9
USDA Section 9006 Program
  • Created as a U.S. Department of Agriculture program
  • Program designed to assist farmers, ranchers and rural small businesses with energy projects
  • This program provides grants and guaranteed loans for renewable energy systems and energy efficiency improvement projects
  • Created as a 5 year program.
  • Congress has funded the program at $22.8 million per year for the first three years (FY06 budget also shows $23M)
  • In 2003 and 2004, a total of $44 million in grants were awarded to 281 projects in 33 states.
  • Currently over 380 grant requests in the system for FY05
10
Who is Eligible?
  • Rural small businesses and agricultural producers can apply
  • The regulation includes the following definitions:*
    • Rural – Any area other than a city of town with population over 50,000.  Cannot be in urbanized area adjacent to such a city or town.


    • Agricultural Producer  -  An individual or entity directly engaged in the production of agricultural products (including farming or ranching) that gets 50% + of their gross income from the operations


    • Small Business - A private entity including a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, cooperative (including most Rural Electric Cooperatives), and certain other electric utilities.
      • Must meet SBA size standards for small business www.sba.gov/size/indextableofsize.html
      • Non-profits excluded
11
 
12
What’s Happening Now?

  • Grants:  2004 NOFA Under Review
  • $11.4 million definite, remaining potential after loan guarantees
  • Loan Guarantees $11.4M with remainder to go to grants
    • $500K RE, $250K EE
    • Combined grant plus loan guarantee cannot exceed 50%
  • Simple application for projects < $100K
  • Regulation now allows year-round submittal
    • 2-3 Grant reviews per year
    • Submit, receive feedback, submit again
    • SUBMIT EARLY
13
Summary of WI (20, $5.6M)
14
Summary of MN (38, $9.7M)
15
Summary of MS (40, $1.5M)
16
Summary of CO (8, $2.0M)
17
What Projects are Eligible?
  • Any renewable energy and energy efficiency project as defined in the law.
  • Requirements for eligible projects:
    • Must be located in a rural area.
    • Must be for a pre-commercial or commercially available and replicable technology.
    • Must be technically feasible.
    • Must have sufficient revenues to provide for operation and maintenance
  • Grants request must not exceed 25% of project costs
    • Minimum grant request: $2,500
    • Renewable Energy:
      • Maximum grant request: $500,000
      • If request is over $50,000, NOFA requires a project-specific feasibility study prepared by a qualifies independent consultant
    • Energy Efficiency
      • Maximum grant request: $250,000
      • If total project costs are over $50,000, NOFA requires an energy audit
  • The applicant must be the owner of the project and control the operation and maintenance of the proposed project.
18
Technical Requirements
  • Different Technology Requirements for:
    • Biomass, Bioenergy
    • Anaerobic Digester
    • Geothermal, electric generation
    • Geothermal, direct use
    • Hydrogen
    • Solar, small (10 kW or smaller)
    • Solar, large (larger than 10 kW)
    • Wind, small (100 kW or smaller)
    • Wind, large (larger than 100 kW)
    • Energy Efficiency


  • USDA has worked with technology experts to develop Guidance on the Technical Requirements for each technology.
    • Designed to help applicants better understand how to respond to the technical requirements of the 2005 NOFA.
    • Available at www.rurdev.usda.gov/rbs/farmbill/ under “Tools and Resources”

19
Energy Efficiency Opportunities
  • Refrigeration Upgrades
  • Lighting Retrofits
  • Heating Efficiency Improvements
  • High Efficiency Circulation and Ventilation - “Big Ass Fans™”
  • Grain dryers
20
 
21
Distributed Energy Technologies
22
Recent trends in generation costs favor small unit sizes.
23
Wind - Sizes and Applications
24
Case Study: Jess Alger’s Ranch, MT - USDA policy
  • Fourth generation MT farmer
  • 1200 acre cattle ranch and wheat farm
  • Offset all electricity used on home and farm operations
  • 100 foot tower
  • Turbine installed September 2003
  • Class 3 winds 12 mph annual average
25
Alger’s Estimated Cost and Production
  • Installed Turbine System - $36,850
    • Site preparation done by J. Algers
  • USDA RESG (25% rebate) - $7,696
  • NCAT USB Funds - $12,500
  • Estimated electricity used 14,200 kWh/yr
  • Estimate electricity produced 18,000 kWh/yr
26
Minwind I and II
“Farmer Cooperative”
  • Two LLCs formed with cooperative principles.
  • Sold membership stock to 66 individuals (33 in each group, required 85% of shares to be owned by farmers)
  • No individual can own more than 15% of the shares.
  • Developed two 1.8 MW projects (to use MN incentive)
  • Built the project in late 2002.
27
Minwind I and Minwind II
  • Goals included:
    • Local ownership
    • Maximize return on investment
    • Create local economic development
    • Research and utilize available incentives
    • Develop a “cookie-cutter” model
    • Maintain cooperative principles
28
Minwind III - IX
  • Seven more Minwind projects received $178,201 grants from USDA in 2003?
    • Essentially, using funds to build interconnection substation to get all 7 projects on the grid.
    • Minwind III-IX will have 147 owners.
  • Signed power purchase contracts with a utility in November 2004?
  • Seven 1.65MW turbines installed in December 2004 near Beaver Creek, MN
29
Rural Electric Cooperatives
  • Three Rural Electric
    Cooperatives received
    USDA funds to develop
    wind projects:
    • Federated Rural Electric
      Association (MN)
      $500,000
    • Nobles Cooperative Electric (MN)
      $500,000
    • Illinois Rural Electric Cooperative (IL)  $438,544
30
Anaerobic Digesters
  • Air Quality benefits
    • Control odors from storage and field application
    • Reduces Greenhouse gases (methane)
    • Controls other emissions (H2S, ammonia)
  • Water Quality benefits
    • Stabilize manure organics (BOD)
    • Significantly reduce pathogens
    • Provide nutrient management predictability and flexibility
  • Return on Investment…Energy Revenues
  • High Capacity Factor
31
What are Anaerobic Digesters?
32
Typical Digester Configuration
33
Project Types
  • On-Farm or Farm Scale:
    • System is owned and operated by farm owner/manager
    • Currently the predominant project type in the U.S.


  • Regional or Centralized Digesters:
    • Off-farm management and operation with a third party
    • Ideally located at a large energy consuming source or interconnection point
34
Solar Energy Applications
  • Often very cost effective
  • Modular and easy to relocate
  • No fuel needs and low maintenance
35
Solar Economic Development
36
Biomass
37
Biomass Plant
38
NREL’s Role: Support the Development of New Industrial Biorefinery Concepts
39
More opportunities exist beyond Ethanol
  • Sugar-derived chemicals
  • Lignin derivatives (BTX (petroluem building blocks), phenols, etc.)
  • Biodiesel & chemicals from vegetable oils
  • Pyrolysis oils from biomass
    • Oxygen rich “cracked stocks”
    • Exploring options for refining/upgrading
  • Gasification of biomass
    • Fischer-Tropsch liquids
    • Hydrogen
    • Chemicals

40
Summary
  • CO potential not yet tapped to receive full benefit from 9006
  • 37 combined w/ emissions regulations will help drive increased market penetration of EERE measures
  • Many economically viable opportunities beyond utility scale wind
  • Leverage distributed generation technologies
  • Don’t forget EE